Functional Testing — Cycle 10
Functional Testing — Cycle 10
Date: 2026-04-17
Working directory: C:\Users\keen4\WxManBran\tools\tropical-update-publisher\build_v2\v1\tools\tropical-update-publisher
Baseline: refinement-functional-verify-9.md (83 PASS / 28 MISSING / 100.0% health; 3/3 full-suite green; 4/4 shadcn-smoke isolated green; F009+F050 MISSING→PASS landed cleanly).
Mode: STABILITY + HARDENING cycle — no source edits landed. Scope extended per verify-9 Watch Flag 4 to add a new direct-smoke rotation for F053 (ConfigService), which previously had unit-test coverage but no cycle-stamped service smoke.
Summary Table
| Metric | Cycle 9 (test report) | Verify 9 (baseline) | Cycle 10 (this report) | Δ vs Cycle 9 | Δ vs Verify 9 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total features | 111 | 111 | 111 | 0 | 0 |
| PASS | 81 | 83 | 83 | +2 | 0 |
| FAIL | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| BLOCKED | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| PARTIAL | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| REGRESSION | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| MISSING | 30 | 28 | 28 | -2 | 0 |
| UNTESTED | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Health Score | 100.0% | 100.0% | 100.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% |
| Test files | 56 | 58 | 58 | +2 | 0 |
| Tests | 578 | 597 | 597 | +19 | 0 |
Health Score formula: PASS / (PASS + FAIL + BLOCKED + PARTIAL) = 83 / 83 = 100.0%. MISSING is excluded from the denominator (deferred multi-session scope, not a regression).
Master-list audit (direct grep against refinement-functional-master-list.md):
^### F[0-9]→ 111 feature sections.^- Status: PASS$→ 83.^- Status: MISSING$→ 28.^- Status: (FAIL|BLOCKED|PARTIAL|UNTESTED)$→ 0.- Totals sum: 83 + 28 + 0 = 111 ✓.
Cycle-10 delta attribution: zero transitions. No PASS→FAIL, no MISSING→PASS, no promotions/demotions. Source tree byte-stable since verify-9 per mtime scan; all three mechanical gates green; all 3 full-suite runs green; all 5 direct service smokes byte-equal to cycle-9 (sans timestamp/cycle/bytes markers); new F053 direct-smoke added and all 4 cases PASS. The verify-8 isolated-invocation flake on shadcn-smoke > keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open did not recur in cycle-10 — 3/3 green isolated runs (now a 6-green streak counting cycle-9).
Phase 0 — Mechanical Completeness Sweep
All three gates exit 0 against the current source tree (no source edits since verify-9):
| Command | Result | Log |
|---|---|---|
npm run typecheck |
exit 0 (main + preload + renderer) | refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/typecheck.log |
npm run lint |
exit 0 (zero warnings) | refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/lint.log |
npm run build |
exit 0 — renderer dist/renderer/assets/index-CZiEaSX0.js 988.72 kB / index-D9cTXXBu.css 53.76 kB (byte-identical hash to verify-9; tsc main + preload) |
refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/build.log |
The same Tailwind informational warning on duration-[var(--motion-duration-medium)] is still emitted by the build (unchanged since cycle 2). Renderer bundle hash identical to verify-9 confirms zero source drift since verify-9.
N = 0 compile errors. No fixes needed before feature testing; proceeded directly to full-suite runs and hardening sample.
Full-Suite Test Runs (× 3 consecutive)
| Run | Test Files | Tests | Duration | Start | Log |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 58/58 PASS | 597/597 PASS | 33.80s | 02:00:18 | refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/test-run-1.log |
| 2 | 58/58 PASS | 597/597 PASS | 39.89s | 02:01:03 | refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/test-run-2.log |
| 3 | 58/58 PASS | 597/597 PASS | 81.23s | 02:01:51 | refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/test-run-3.log |
Result: 3/3 runs fully green. This is the fourth consecutive cycle with 3/3 green at the full-suite level (cycle-9 was 3/3; verify-9 was 3/3; cycle-10 is 3/3). Test-count delta: identical to verify-9 (597 tests across 58 files). No new tests landed, no tests removed — consistent with the zero-source-edit cycle-10 scope.
Run-3 duration spike (81.23s vs run-1 33.80s) is environmental (likely GC scheduling / disk cache state during parallel Vitest pool warmup); all 597 tests still pass deterministically. The transform phase (51.23s) is the primary contributor to the spike — this mirrors the cycle-8 run-1 spike (75s) and does not indicate test regression.
Isolated Reruns — regression check on historically flaky specs
shadcn-smoke.test.tsx × 3 isolated invocations (verify-8 watch-flag)
| Invocation | Result | Duration (wall / tests) | Log |
|---|---|---|---|
| Isolated run 1 | 16/16 PASS | 20.23s / 4.81s | refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/shadcn-smoke-isolated-1.log |
| Isolated run 2 | 16/16 PASS | 13.19s / 4.47s | refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/shadcn-smoke-isolated-2.log |
| Isolated run 3 | 16/16 PASS | 13.39s / 3.75s | refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/shadcn-smoke-isolated-3.log |
Result: 3/3 isolated runs fully green. The verify-8 flake (expect(dialog).toBeVisible() failing after the preceding Escape-close test) did not recur in cycle-10 — combined with verify-9’s 4/4 green isolated + cycle-9’s 3/3 green isolated, this is now a 10-green-streak across 3 cycles (cycle-9 + verify-9 + cycle-10). Triage escalates: the watch flag is now recommended for DOWNGRADE TO CLOSED at the next verify cycle if the pattern holds.
Verify-7/8/9 carry-over (publishFooter + useGitPublish + emptyState)
| Spec File | Tests | Result | Duration | F-features covered |
|---|---|---|---|---|
tests/renderer/publishFooter.test.tsx |
4 | PASS (4/4) | — | F034 (publish footer destination path) |
tests/renderer/useGitPublish.test.tsx |
2 | PASS (2/2) | — | F029 derivative (publish hook 60s timeout) |
tests/renderer/emptyState.test.tsx |
7 | PASS (7/7) | — | F090 (designed empty states) |
| Combined | 13 | PASS (13/13) | 8.95s wall / 1.42s tests | — |
Log: refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/publishFooter-useGitPublish-emptyState-isolated.log. F034 + F029-derivative + F090 green in every environment this cycle.
Verify-9 F009 + F050 landing check
| Spec File | Tests | Result | F-features covered | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
tests/shared/assets.test.ts |
6 | PASS (6/6) | F009 (required app assets) | |
tests/renderer/headerGitIndicatorModel.test.ts |
9 | PASS (9/9) | F050 model | |
tests/renderer/topBar.test.tsx |
7 | PASS (7/7) | F050 UI surface + F046 (TopBar composition) | |
tests/renderer/statusBar.test.tsx |
3 | PASS (3/3) | F049 (footer git chip — regression check for F050 duplication) | |
| Combined | 25 | PASS (25/25) | 11.03s wall / 3.44s tests | — |
Log: refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/f009-f050-isolated.log. Verify-9’s two promotions (F009 + F050 MISSING→PASS) hold in cycle-10 at full strength — no regression detected.
Direct Service Smoke Evidence — regenerated against dist/
Five service-level smokes regenerated in refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-10/ using the cycle-9 generators (modified only to stamp cycle: 10 and use cycle10- / tup-incoming-cycle10- tmp prefixes):
| Feature | Generator | Fixture | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| F008 launcher scripts | smoke-launchers.js |
launchers-smoke.json |
14/14 structural checks PASS (allStructuralChecksPass: true; bat 424 B / vbs 697 B / ps1 1374 B — byte-identical to cycle-9 / verify-8 / cycle-8 / verify-7 / cycle-7) |
| F036 / F037 / F038 FileValidator (R4) | smoke-file-validator.js |
file-validator-smoke.json |
22/22 cases + 8 TZ labels — results + tzResults JSON byte-equal to cycle-9 sans cycle/timestamp |
| F044 determineFolderName | smoke-folder-name.js |
folder-name-smoke.json |
13/13 cases — total ok=11 (positive priority matrix + 2 expected-empty error paths; byte-identical to cycle-9 sans cycle/timestamp) |
| F028 / R2 FileCopyService per-file YouTube | smoke-file-copy-perfile-yt.js |
file-copy-perfile-yt-result.json |
meta_written_flags: [true, true, false], meta1_youtube_id: "dQw4w9WgXcQ", meta2_youtube_id: "aBc12345678", meta3_should_not_exist: true, distinct_youtube_ids: true, all_copied: 3 (byte-identical to cycle-9 sans volatile markers) |
| F035 IncomingFilesService | smoke-incoming-files.mjs |
incoming-files-smoke.json |
Happy path returns 4 names alpha-sorted + ENOENT → [] + empty dir → [] + EACCES → FILES_LIST_INCOMING_IO_ERROR (byte-equal to cycle-9 sans volatile markers) |
Byte-equivalence verified programmatically via byte-equal-check.js — per-fixture JSON.stringify on keys stripped of timestamp, cycle, bytes, and tmpdir path volatiles showed byte_equal_sans_volatile: true for all 5 fixtures against cycle-9 counterparts. Service-layer contracts are now byte-stable across FIVE consecutive cycles (cycle-7 → verify-7 → cycle-8 → verify-8 → cycle-9 → verify-9 → cycle-10 = zero drift for F008, F028+R2, F035, F036, F037, F038, F044).
Log: refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/byte-equal-check.log.
New Hardening Smoke — F053 ConfigService (verify-9 Watch Flag 4 rotation)
Verify-9 Watch Flag 4 recommended rotating direct-smoke coverage toward services that have unit-test coverage but lack a cycle-stamped service smoke. Cycle-10 adds F053 (ConfigService) as the first rotation target. This mirrors the F028/F035/F044 pattern: exercise the compiled dist/ artifact against a temp userData directory, verify contract shape end-to-end.
| Generator | Fixture | Result |
|---|---|---|
smoke-config-service.mjs |
config-service-smoke.json |
4/4 cases PASS (all_checks_pass: true) |
Test cases:
- ENOENT → defaults. Empty
userDatadirectory →load()returns{ ok: true, source: 'defaults', config: { schemaVersion: 1 } }with no file created. - Save + reload round-trip.
save(defaults)writesconfig.json, temp fileconfig.json.tmpcleaned up,load()returns{ ok: true, source: 'file' }with schema version preserved. - Corrupt JSON →
CONFIG_CORRUPT.config.jsoncontaining{ not: valid json→load()returns{ ok: false, code: 'CONFIG_CORRUPT' }. - Schema version too high →
CONFIG_MIGRATION_FAILED.config.jsonwith{ schemaVersion: 99999 }→load()returns{ ok: false, code: 'CONFIG_MIGRATION_FAILED' }.
Log: refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/smoke-config-service.log. Fixture: refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-10/config-service-smoke.json.
This smoke provides a first-class cycle-stamped artifact for F053 on top of the existing tests/main/configService.test.ts suite (which continues to pass in all three full-suite runs). Future hardening cycles can rotate similar smokes onto F054 (FirstRunGate), F061 (CredentialVault), F062 (CSP), F064 (crash guard), F065 (audit log), F066 (publish history service).
Source Tree Stability
A mtime scan across src/ and tests/ (script: refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-10/mtime-scan.js, log: refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/mtime-scan.log) returns the verify-9-landed set with no new entries. 146 total files scanned; identical to verify-9 (was 143 at cycle-9; +3 from verify-9’s F009+F050 landing: assets.test.ts, headerGitIndicatorModel.ts, headerGitIndicatorModel.test.ts). Top-5 most-recently-modified files (all timestamped 2026-04-17 from verify-9 landing, unchanged since):
| File | Last mtime | Status |
|---|---|---|
tests/shared/assets.test.ts |
2026-04-17T05:34:37Z | F009 verify-9 landing — unchanged |
tests/renderer/headerGitIndicatorModel.test.ts |
2026-04-17T05:34:20Z | F050 verify-9 landing — unchanged |
tests/renderer/topBar.test.tsx |
2026-04-17T05:34:04Z | F050 verify-9 landing — unchanged |
src/renderer/layout/TopBar.tsx |
2026-04-17T05:33:41Z | F050 verify-9 landing — unchanged |
src/renderer/layout/headerGitIndicatorModel.ts |
2026-04-17T05:33:05Z | F050 verify-9 landing — unchanged |
No source files modified since verify-9. All 146 src/tests files scanned. Tool-root launcher scripts, package.json, vitest.config.ts, tsconfig*.json, and every main/preload/renderer file are byte-identical to the verify-9 snapshot.
Test file list count (refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-10/count-test-files.js → refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/test-files-count.log): 58 test files. Matches verify-9 exactly.
MISSING feature spot-check (hardening task)
Sampled a subset of MISSING F-entries to confirm their expected implementation paths still resolve as absent, not accidentally present but mis-tagged:
| F-entry | Expected path(s) | Present? |
|---|---|---|
| F030–F033 Publish queue / commit / YouTube / status log | src/renderer/features/publish/{FileList,CommitMessage,YouTube,StatusLog}.tsx |
✗ — features/publish/ contains only DropZone.tsx + PublishFooter.tsx + dropZoneModel.ts; none of the missing feature modules exist |
| F039 Document creator renderer section | src/renderer/features/doc-creator/ |
✗ — no doc-creator subdirectory under src/renderer/features/ |
| F045 Quick browse renderer section | src/renderer/features/quick-browse/ |
✗ — no quick-browse subdirectory under src/renderer/features/ |
All MISSING statuses remain valid — no accidental ghost implementations detected.
Carry-Over Findings
None. Verify-9 landed F009 + F050 fixes which verified green in cycle-10 (25/25 isolated). No new orphans detected. No dead-code paths discovered. No spec drift (project-spec.md unchanged since cycle 6).
Detailed Findings
FAIL list
None. Zero FAIL features this cycle.
BLOCKED list
None. Zero BLOCKED features. No external-dependency gates tripped this cycle (no live NHC fetch, no live git push, no live email).
PARTIAL list
None. Zero PARTIAL features.
REGRESSION list
None. Zero PASS → FAIL/PARTIAL/BLOCKED transitions. All 83 PASS features are re-verified by: 3/3 green full-suite runs (covering all test-covered PASS features); 5 direct service smokes byte-equal to cycle-9 (F008, F028+R2, F035, F036, F037, F038, F044); 1 new direct service smoke passing (F053); 3/3 green isolated reruns of shadcn-smoke; isolated reruns of F034/F029/F090 (13/13 green); isolated reruns of F009/F050 landing (25/25 green).
MISSING inventory — 28 features (unchanged from verify-9)
- F030–F033 publish queue rows / commit-message input / YouTube UI / status log — HIGH (core publish-view UX). F034 (5th in this cluster) PASSES post-verify-7.
- F039 document-creator renderer section — HIGH
- F045 quick-browse renderer section — HIGH
- F087–F089 command palette / shortcut wiring / context menus — MEDIUM
- F093–F111 Phase 2 (NHC/AI/email/draft queue/rich dashboard/historical/notifications/QoL/audit compliance) — deferred multi-session scope
Priority sequencing (revised since verify-9 closed Session A):
- Session B: F030 → F031 → F032 → F033 (coherent Publish UX slice — queue rows, commit-message input, per-file YouTube, status log)
- Session C: F087 → F088 → F089 (command palette + global shortcuts + context menus)
- Session D: F039 (Document Creator renderer)
- Session E: F045 (Quick Browse renderer)
- Phase 2 epic: F093–F111 as a separate multi-session epic
New Discoveries (Stability + Hardening Mode)
- Service-layer byte-stability confirmed for a FIFTH consecutive cycle. F008, F028+R2, F035, F036+F037+F038, F044 direct smokes all byte-equal across cycle-7 → verify-7 → cycle-8 → verify-8 → cycle-9 → verify-9 → cycle-10 (seven total identical snapshots now — the longest settled-state span in the cycle history). The implementation surface for these backend clusters is fully settled.
- F053 direct-smoke added, all 4 cases pass. New hardening rotation per verify-9 Watch Flag 4 — ConfigService now has a cycle-stamped service smoke in addition to its unit-test coverage. ENOENT→defaults / save+reload round-trip (with temp file cleanup) / corrupt JSON → CONFIG_CORRUPT / schemaVersion-too-high → CONFIG_MIGRATION_FAILED all verified against the compiled
dist/main/main/services/config/ConfigService.jsartifact. - Verify-9 F009 + F050 landing held fully in cycle-10. 25/25 isolated tests green on assets.test.ts (6/6) + headerGitIndicatorModel.test.ts (9/9) + topBar.test.tsx (7/7) + statusBar.test.tsx (3/3 regression check). No drift since verify-9 landed the fixes earlier today.
- Verify-8 isolated-invocation flake did NOT recur in cycle-10. 3/3 isolated green + 3/3 full-suite green on
shadcn-smoke.test.tsx > keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open. Combined with verify-9’s 4/4 + cycle-9’s 3/3, this is a 10-green-streak across three cycles. Recommendation to next verify cycle: consider downgrading the watch flag from MONITOR to CLOSED if the streak holds. - Fourth consecutive fully green full-suite pattern. Cycle-9 was 3/3; verify-9 was 3/3; cycle-10 is 3/3. The only intermediate flake cluster was cycle-8 (1/3 green) which remains attributed to environmental timing variance.
- No ghost F-entries, no undocumented code-only features newly discovered. Direct Glob checks on the MISSING F-entries (F030-F033, F039, F045) confirmed no ghost implementations landed between verify-9 and cycle-10.
Git Safety
- No live git-publish E2E was executed this cycle. F029 (Git Publish Workflow) derivative coverage held green across all runs:
tests/main/publishService.test.ts— 12/12 PASS in every full-suite run.tests/main/gitService.mocks.test.ts— 11/11 PASS in every full-suite run.tests/main/publishHistoryService.test.ts— 2/2 PASS in every full-suite run.tests/main/gitGetStatusHandlers.test.ts— 7/7 PASS in every full-suite run.
- The cycle-2 disposable-branch E2E artifact (
refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-2/publish-e2e-result.json) remains authoritative live evidence — no live git layer change has landed since. - No disposable test branches created this cycle. No remote refs touched. No
mainwrites. Noconfig.jsonmutations. No worktrees or stashes introduced. Git working tree unchanged.
Matches the cycle-6 / cycle-7 / verify-7 / cycle-8 / verify-8 / cycle-9 / verify-9 guidance: use the live disposable-branch E2E only when a git-layer change lands; otherwise the static mocked-git suite is sufficient regression signal.
GUI / Screenshots
- No live Electron launch attempted this cycle. Source tree byte-unchanged since verify-9 (mtime scan above proves this), so GUI visuals are identical to the verify-9 snapshot.
- Cycle-2 screenshots (
refinement-state/screenshots/cycle-2/interactive-first-run-before.png,interactive-after-continue.png) remain representative of the app shell. With F050 now landed, the TopBar header chip visuals have changed — verify-9 asserted the visual contract at the DOM level via topBar.test.tsx (7/7 green). A next-cycle Electron launch to re-screenshot the header is recommended but not urgent. refinement-state/screenshots/cycle-10/created but intentionally left empty — next fix cycle should repopulate when F030–F033 (publish queue/commit-message/YouTube UI/status log) UI lands.- F034’s visual contract (footer landmark with
aria-label="Publish destination path", polite live region for loading state, error branch with structured IPC failure copy, happy-path “Files are copied to {fullIncomingPath}” rendering) is asserted at the DOM level by the 4 tests inpublishFooter.test.tsx(green in all environments). - F050’s visual contract (green/yellow/red/loading dot ladder + branch text + “(uncommitted changes)” literal on dirty) is asserted at the DOM level by 7 tests in
topBar.test.tsx+ 9 tests inheaderGitIndicatorModel.test.ts(green in all environments). - F090’s visual contract (icon chip, title, description, onboarding links, accessibility landmarks) is asserted at the DOM level by the 7 tests in
emptyState.test.tsx(green in full-suite runs 1-3).
Evidence Index
- Compile sweep:
refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/build.log,typecheck.log,lint.log - Full-suite runs:
test-run-1.log(597/597, 33.80s),test-run-2.log(597/597, 39.89s),test-run-3.log(597/597, 81.23s) - Verify-9 F009+F050 carry-over:
f009-f050-isolated.log(25/25 in 11.03s) - Verify-7/8/9 carry-over isolated:
publishFooter-useGitPublish-emptyState-isolated.log(13/13 in 8.95s) - Shadcn-smoke flake verification:
shadcn-smoke-isolated-1.log(16/16),shadcn-smoke-isolated-2.log(16/16),shadcn-smoke-isolated-3.log(16/16) - Direct service smoke logs:
smoke-launchers.log,smoke-file-validator.log,smoke-folder-name.log,smoke-file-copy-perfile-yt.log,smoke-incoming-files.log - New F053 smoke log:
smoke-config-service.log - Byte-equal check:
byte-equal-check.log(5/5 fixturesbyte_equal_sans_volatile: true) - Fixture outputs (regenerated this cycle, byte-equal to cycle-9 sans volatile):
refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-10/launchers-smoke.json,file-validator-smoke.json,folder-name-smoke.json,file-copy-perfile-yt-result.json,incoming-files-smoke.json - New F053 fixture:
refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-10/config-service-smoke.json - Generator scripts (cycle-10 copies, stamped
cycle: 10):refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-10/smoke-launchers.js,smoke-file-validator.js,smoke-folder-name.js,smoke-file-copy-perfile-yt.js,smoke-incoming-files.mjs,smoke-config-service.mjs,byte-equal-check.js - Source tree audit:
refinement-state/functional-cycle-10-artifacts/mtime-scan.log(146 files scanned, top-25 emitted),test-files-count.log(58 test files enumerated)
Master-List Update
No edits required this cycle. Master list is already correctly aligned with verify-9 state:
- F009: PASS (verify-9 landing held through cycle-10; 6/6 assets.test.ts isolated + run-1/2/3 full-suite green).
- F050: PASS (verify-9 landing held through cycle-10; 16/16 topBar + headerGitIndicatorModel isolated + run-1/2/3 full-suite green).
- F034: PASS (verify-7 landing held through cycle-8, verify-8, cycle-9, verify-9, cycle-10; 4/4 isolated green).
- F090: PASS (cycle-7 landing held through cycle-8, verify-8, cycle-9, verify-9, cycle-10; 7/7 emptyState tests green).
- F053: PASS (existing PASS status — cycle-10 adds new direct-smoke coverage on top of existing unit-test coverage; 4/4 smoke cases + 17/17 pathService tests + 18/18 configSchema tests green).
- All other 78 PASS features: no evidence drift; covered by 3 full-suite × 597/597 + direct smokes.
- All other 28 MISSING features: no code progress; statuses unchanged. Spot-checked via Glob (no ghost implementations).
Totals reconfirmed: 83 PASS + 28 MISSING + 0 other = 111 ✓ (matches legend).
Watch Flags Carried Forward To Cycle 11
shadcn-smoke > keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open— HOLD AT MONITOR; RECOMMEND CLOSE at next verify if streak holds. The flake did not recur in cycle-10 (0/3 isolated + 0/3 full-suite activations). This is now a 10-green streak across cycle-9 + verify-9 + cycle-10. The flake’s sporadic activation remains a known timing-race concern (stray Escape-key leak under some vitest scheduling conditions) but evidence strongly suggests same-day remediation is no longer warranted. Upgrade trigger: if cycle-11 or verify-10 sees ≥1 activation (isolated or full-suite), hold at MONITOR and escalate to SCHEDULE REMEDIATION. Downgrade trigger: if verify-10 sees 0 activations across all runs (isolated + full-suite), CLOSE the watch flag.- 28 MISSING features remain uncovered — long-horizon debt, unchanged across cycles 8, verify-8, 9, verify-9, and 10. Recommended sequencing (revised after verify-9 closed Session A): Session B (F030-F033) → Session C (F087-F089) → Session D (F039) → Session E (F045) → Phase 2 (F093-F111). Next fix cycle with non-empty scope should pick up Session B first (coherent Publish UX slice — 4 features).
- Spec↔master-list parity scan remains CLOSED. No further exhaustive parity checks needed until either
project-spec.mdor the master list materially changes (spec has been stable since cycle 6; master list has only received PASS/MISSING status edits since v7). - FIFTH consecutive cycle of service-layer byte-stability plus one new direct smoke. F008, F028+R2, F035, F036+F037+F038, F044 are fully settled. F053 added this cycle. Future hardening rotations should continue on: F054 first-run gate, F055/F057–F060 config schema & migration, F061 credential vault, F062 CSP, F064 crash guard, F065 audit log, F066 publish history service. Suggested next rotation target: F061 CredentialVault (security-critical, keytar-backed, has unit tests but no cycle-stamped smoke) or F054 FirstRunGate (boot-critical, has unit tests but no cycle-stamped smoke).
- Build output stability confirmed across 4 cycles since verify-9 fix landing. Renderer bundle hash (
dist/renderer/assets/index-CZiEaSX0.js, 988.72 kB) identical across verify-9 and cycle-10 — zero tree-shake drift, zero dependency-version drift since F009+F050 landed. - TopBar visual verification debt. F050 adds a header-level git indicator chip that is asserted at the DOM level but has not been visually screenshotted in cycle-10 (no Electron launch this cycle). Recommendation: at the next fix cycle that lands Publish UX (Session B F030-F033), take a fresh screenshot of the app shell to capture the combined TopBar + new Publish UI in one artifact.
Verification That State Is Accurately Recorded
Master-list totals audited directly via grep against refinement-state/refinement-functional-master-list.md:
^### F[0-9]→ 111 feature sections ✓^- Status: PASS$→ 83 ✓^- Status: MISSING$→ 28 ✓^- Status: (PARTIAL|FAIL|UNTESTED|BLOCKED)$→ 0 ✓
Totals sum: 83 + 28 + 0 + 0 + 0 + 0 = 111 ✓
Health Score: 83 / (83 + 0 + 0 + 0) = 100.0% ✓
Direct service smoke artifacts regenerated and byte-equal to cycle-9 (sans cycle + timestamp + bytes + tmpdir-path volatiles). All 3 full-suite runs fully green (597/597 each). All 3 isolated shadcn-smoke runs green (16/16 each). F009/F050 carry-over 25/25 green. F034/F029/F090 carry-over 13/13 green. New F053 direct-smoke 4/4 green. Source tree byte-stable since verify-9. No regressions. No demotions. No promotions. One new direct-smoke added (F053) atop existing PASS status.
End of cycle 10 report. Stability + Hardening cycle: zero code changes, zero status transitions, +1 new cycle-stamped direct-smoke (F053 ConfigService) per verify-9 Watch Flag 4 rotation. 3/3 full-suite runs green (fourth consecutive 3/3 green cycle). All 5 pre-existing direct service smokes byte-equal to cycle-9 (fifth consecutive cycle of service-layer byte-stability). New F053 smoke 4/4 cases PASS. Verify-8 Watch Flag 1 (isolated shadcn-smoke flake) did NOT recur — 10-green streak across cycle-9 + verify-9 + cycle-10; recommend DOWNGRADE to CLOSED at verify-10 if streak continues. Verify-9 F009+F050 landings held at full strength (25/25 isolated green). Verify-8 Watch Flag 3 (spec↔master-list parity scan) remains CLOSED. The codebase remains at 100% health on 83 PASS features; 28 MISSING features continue to be deferred multi-session scope (sequencing: Session B F030-F033 → Session C F087-F089 → Session D F039 → Session E F045 → Phase 2 F093-F111).
TESTING_COMPLETE