Functional Verification — Cycle 10

Date: 2026-04-17 Working directory: C:\Users\keen4\WxManBran\tools\tropical-update-publisher\build_v2\v1\tools\tropical-update-publisher Baseline: refinement-functional-cycle-10.md (83 PASS / 28 MISSING / 100.0% health) + refinement-functional-fixes-10.md (Session B landing — F030 + F031 + F032 + F033 MISSING→PASS). Mode: Post-fix verification pass. Re-test every feature the fix log promoted, sample a regression slice, re-run isolated checks on historically flaky specs, confirm master-list parity.

Verification Results (Post-Fix)

Metric Pre-Fix (cycle 10) Post-Fix (this verify) Δ
Total features 111 111 0
PASS 83 87 +4
FAIL 0 0 0
BLOCKED 0 0 0
PARTIAL 0 0 0
REGRESSION 0 0 0
MISSING 28 24 -4
UNTESTED 0 0 0
Health Score 100.0% 100.0% 0.0%
Test files 58 66 +8
Tests 597 659 +62

Health Score formula: PASS / (PASS + FAIL + BLOCKED + PARTIAL) = 87 / 87 = 100.0%. MISSING remains excluded from the denominator (deferred multi-session scope; not a regression).

Master-list audit (direct grep against the current refinement-functional-master-list.md):

  • ^### F[0-9] → 111 feature sections
  • ^- Status: PASS$ → 87
  • ^- Status: MISSING$ → 24
  • ^- Status: (FAIL|BLOCKED|PARTIAL|UNTESTED)$ → 0
  • Totals sum: 87 + 24 + 0 = 111 ✓

Delta attribution: exactly four MISSING→PASS transitions — F030, F031, F032, F033 — all cited by the fix log, all verified with fresh evidence this pass. No PASS→anything demotions. No new FAIL/BLOCKED/PARTIAL.

Step 1 — Re-test Of Promoted Features (Session B: F030-F033)

Session B features verified end-to-end via isolated Vitest invocations on the 9 directly-related test files. The isolated run bypasses the full-suite parallel pool so flakes caused by CPU contention cannot mask real failures here.

Feature Isolated Test Files Tests Result
F030 File queue rows, parsed metadata, row actions queueRowModel.test.ts, usePublishQueueStore.test.ts, fileList.test.tsx, publishPlaceholder.test.tsx 33 33/33 PASS
F031 Commit message input + upload state machine commitMessageModel.test.ts, commitMessage.test.tsx 16 16/16 PASS
F032 YouTube URL UI (global + per-row) youTubeSection.test.tsx, plus per-row in fileList.test.tsx, plus reapply in usePublishQueueStore.test.ts 4 (direct) + 6 (per-row sharing fileList) + 2 (store sharing usePublishQueueStore) All green
F033 Status log UI + live git:log stream statusLogModel.test.ts, statusLog.test.tsx 11 11/11 PASS
Combined isolated bundle 9 test files 64 64/64 PASS (13.07s)

Log: refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/session-b-isolated.log. Every new spec test from fix-10 (the 62 net-new tests) executed with green results in isolation — reproducing the fix log’s own claims.

F030 verification — deeper look

  • Queue row dedup (spec §12): queueRowModel.test.ts > addPaths rejects duplicate original basenames / rejects duplicate effective basenames after conversion PASS in isolation. The legacy-→-NEW collision case exercises the conversion path to confirm a legacy filename’s converted form is compared against existing NEW rows.
  • Per-row YouTube override (spec §19 R2): queueRowModel.test.ts > applyYouTubeUrl sets youtubeUrl/youtubeValid/youtubeId on the target row only + fileList.test.tsx > typing an invalid per-row YouTube URL marks the input aria-invalid confirm both happy and error paths.
  • Clear All + per-row remove: fileList.test.tsx > clicking Clear All empties the queue + > per-row Remove button deletes that row only PASS in the isolated run.
  • PublishPlaceholder integration: publishPlaceholder.test.tsx > queued docx paths appear in the FileList region after browse selection PASS — confirms the route wires enqueuePaths correctly and the new FileList region (data-testid="file-list-region") renders under the drop zone.

F031 verification — deeper look

  • Commit message state machine (§6.7): commitMessageModel.test.ts > defaultCommitMessageFor singular / plural / zero PASS. The 12 test file covers all pure helper branches (singular/plural/zero copy, all four button label variants, all five enable/disable boundaries).
  • Upload button state gates: commitMessage.test.tsx > disables Upload when queue is empty (boundary: empty queue) + > labels the button based on count and toggles enablement on commit-msg edits (happy §6.7) + > clicking Upload invokes gitPublish with valid descriptors (happy path §8) + > disables Upload when any row has a YouTube error (blocking gate §11) all PASS.
  • Integration with useGitPublish: commitMessage.test.tsx > clicking Upload invokes gitPublish with valid descriptors captures the PublishFileDescriptor payload and confirms youtubeId flows through.

F032 verification — deeper look

  • Global YouTube input (§6.5): youTubeSection.test.tsx all 4 tests PASS — empty initial state, valid URL → success chip + extracted id, invalid URL → aria-invalid + error chip, store-controlled value mirrors.
  • Per-row override: already covered under F030/F031 tests.
  • Reapply-on-enqueue (§11 same-batch semantics): usePublishQueueStore.test.ts > setGlobalYouTubeUrl re-applies to all existing rows + > newly enqueued rows inherit the current global YouTube URL PASS in isolation.

F033 verification — deeper look

  • Preload fix (load-bearing): src/preload/index.ts:153 now implements gitStreamSubscribe: (callback) => { ... ipcRenderer.on(GIT_LOG_EVENT_CHANNEL, listener); ... return () => ipcRenderer.removeListener(...); }. No NOT_IMPLEMENTED throw. Verified by direct Grep on the file. The fix log claim matches the code.
  • 50-entry FIFO + icon + timestamp (§13): statusLogModel.test.ts > appendLogEntry trims FIFO at 50 entries + > formatEntryTimestamp returns en-US 12-hour format with seconds + > iconForLevel maps info/success/warn/error → • ✓ ⚠ ✗ all PASS (7/7 isolated).
  • Live stream integration: statusLog.test.tsx > installs the gitStreamSubscribe listener on mount and forwards events asserts that a mock gitStreamSubscribe callback fired from windowApiMock.gitStreamSubscribe delivers entries to the rendered log — confirming the preload → store → DOM path end-to-end.
  • Clear button + auto-scroll: statusLog.test.tsx > Clear button empties the store-backed log PASS. Auto-scroll is not asserted (jsdom scrollHeight returns 0) but the ref wiring is compile-checked.

Conclusion: All four promoted features verified working with fresh evidence from THIS verify pass. No fix is rejected.

Step 2 — Mechanical Gates Against Post-Fix Source Tree

All three gates exit 0 against the fix-10 source tree:

Command Result Log
npm run typecheck exit 0 (main + preload + renderer, all three tsconfigs clean) refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/typecheck.log
npm run lint exit 0 (zero warnings across .ts and .tsx) refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/lint.log
npm run build exit 0 — renderer dist/renderer/assets/index-Dgd89L0d.js 1,030.80 kB / index-ngqALzJp.css 54.24 kB (+42.08 kB JS vs cycle-10’s 988.72 kB — expected from Session B landing: Zustand store, new components, useGitLogStream hook); tsc main + preload clean refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/build.log

The same Tailwind informational warning on duration-[var(--motion-duration-medium)] is still emitted — unchanged since cycle 2 and not introduced by Session B.

N = 0 compile errors. Renderer bundle hash changed from cycle-10 (index-CZiEaSX0.js) to fix-10 (index-Dgd89L0d.js) as expected — Session B added real new modules. Bundle growth (+42 kB JS / +0.48 kB CSS) is in line with the scope: 4 new components, 2 new pure models, 1 new hook, 1 new store, 1 new preload branch.

Step 3 — Full-Suite Test Runs (× 3 consecutive)

Run Test Files Tests Duration Start Log
1 66/66 PASS 659/659 PASS 71.35s 03:06:34 refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/test-run-1.log
2 65/66 PASS 658/659 (1 flake) 61.71s 03:07:56 refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/test-run-2.log
3 66/66 PASS 659/659 PASS 45.02s 03:09:17 refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/test-run-3.log

Result: 2/3 runs fully green; 1/3 runs showed a single-test flake — tests/renderer/shadcn-smoke.test.tsx > App + Dialog smoke > opens the dialog and shows the titled input field (happy path) failing on expect(screen.getByText('Publish label')).toBeInTheDocument() at line 119. Full failure context: dialog transitioned to visible per the preceding waitFor, but the inner title node was not queryable at the moment the next synchronous assertion fired.

Flake triage

This is not the verify-8 watch flag (which was a different test in the same spec: keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open). It is a new timing flake on a different test within the same spec:

  • Isolated reruns of the failing test: 3/3 PASS in isolation (below). Failure does not reproduce outside the full-suite parallel pool.
  • Parallel pool pressure: test-run-2 hit 61.71s (vs run-1 71s / run-3 45s); both test-run-1 and test-run-3 passed the same test cleanly.
  • Nature of the flake: waitFor(dialog visible) passed but the subsequent synchronous getByText('Publish label') could not find the text. This is a classic jsdom microtask-ordering race: React scheduled the dialog content in a follow-up tick that happened to not complete before the next assertion under CPU pressure.
  • Regression assessment: NOT A REGRESSION. No production code path is broken; the issue is test-side timing brittleness. The feature the test covers (Dialog component rendering a title + input field) is shown working by all other tests in the same spec plus the isolated reruns.

Triage escalation: this is a NEW watch flag — shadcn-smoke > opens the dialog and shows the titled input field (happy path) under parallel load. Classified as MONITOR level (same as the verify-8 keeps keyboard focus flake watch). Remediation recommendation for next cycle: wrap the getByText('Publish label') call in its own waitFor to allow React’s render-after-visible-state tick to complete before assertion. This is a one-line test-only fix; production code is unaffected.

Step 4 — Isolated Reruns On Historically Flaky Specs

shadcn-smoke.test.tsx × 3 isolated invocations (verify-8 carry-forward watch flag)

Invocation Result Duration (wall / tests) Log
Isolated run 1 16/16 PASS 15.22s / 4.00s refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/shadcn-smoke-isolated-1.log
Isolated run 2 16/16 PASS 8.12s / 1.71s refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/shadcn-smoke-isolated-2.log
Isolated run 3 16/16 PASS 8.07s / 1.98s refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/shadcn-smoke-isolated-3.log

Result: 3/3 isolated runs fully green. Both the verify-8 watch-flag test (keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open) and the new flake candidate (opens the dialog and shows the titled input field) pass cleanly in isolated mode. The flake from test-run-2 did not reproduce in any of the three isolated runs.

The verify-8 watch flag (keeps keyboard focus) has now held green for 4 consecutive cycles (cycle-9 + verify-9 + cycle-10 + verify-10) — the one activation was in this pass’s test-run-2 but it was a different test, not the watch-flagged one. Per fix-10’s cycle-2 cascade logic this would still support DOWNGRADE of the verify-8 flag to CLOSED; a new MONITOR entry opens for the new flake candidate instead.

Session B isolated bundle (new fix-10 coverage)

Spec File Tests Result Category
tests/renderer/queueRowModel.test.ts 17 PASS (17/17) F030 pure model
tests/renderer/usePublishQueueStore.test.ts 8 PASS (8/8) F030 + F031 + F032 store
tests/renderer/fileList.test.tsx 6 PASS (6/6) F030 UI + F032 per-row
tests/renderer/commitMessageModel.test.ts 12 PASS (12/12) F031 pure model
tests/renderer/commitMessage.test.tsx 4 PASS (4/4) F031 UI + gitPublish wire-up
tests/renderer/youTubeSection.test.tsx 4 PASS (4/4) F032 global UI
tests/renderer/statusLogModel.test.ts 7 PASS (7/7) F033 pure model
tests/renderer/statusLog.test.tsx 4 PASS (4/4) F033 UI + stream forwarding
tests/renderer/publishPlaceholder.test.tsx 2 PASS (2/2) F030 route integration
Combined 64 PASS (64/64) 13.07s wall / 10.17s tests

Log: refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/session-b-isolated.log.

Verify-7/8/9 carry-over regression sample (F009, F029-derivative, F034, F049, F050, F090)

Spec File Tests Result F-features covered
tests/shared/assets.test.ts 6 PASS (6/6) F009 required app assets
tests/renderer/useGitPublish.test.tsx 2 PASS (2/2) F029 derivative (publish hook 60s timeout)
tests/renderer/headerGitIndicatorModel.test.ts 9 PASS (9/9) F050 pure model
tests/renderer/publishFooter.test.tsx 4 PASS (4/4) F034 publish destination path
tests/renderer/statusBar.test.tsx 3 PASS (3/3) F049 footer git chip
tests/renderer/topBar.test.tsx 7 PASS (7/7) F050 UI + F046 TopBar composition
tests/renderer/emptyState.test.tsx 7 PASS (7/7) F090 designed empty states
Combined 38 PASS (38/38) 12.17s wall / 5.38s tests

Log: refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/carryover-isolated.log. Zero regressions on previously-promoted features.

Step 5 — Regression Sample On PASS Features Near Modified Code

Per the prompt: “Pick features near modified code areas. Re-run tests.” Fix-10 modified code in these areas:

  • src/renderer/features/publish/ (added queueRowModel, commitMessageModel, statusLogModel, FileList, CommitMessage, YouTubeSection, StatusLog)
  • src/renderer/stores/ (added usePublishQueueStore)
  • src/renderer/hooks/ (added useGitLogStream)
  • src/preload/index.ts (replaced gitStreamSubscribe stub with real listener)
  • src/renderer/routes/Placeholders.tsx (wired Session B components into PublishPlaceholder)
  • tests/renderer/windowApiMock.ts (added gitStreamSubscribe slot)
  • tests/renderer/publishPlaceholder.test.tsx (rewritten to cover new region)
  • tests/renderer/smoke.test.tsx (hero copy assertion updated)

Regression-adjacent PASS features sampled and re-verified in the carryover isolated bundle above:

F-entry Why selected Status Evidence
F029 Git publish workflow Session B wires useGitPublish into CommitMessage PASS (holds) useGitPublish.test.tsx 2/2 isolated + publishService.test.ts 12/12 in full-suite runs 1+3
F034 Publish footer destination path Renders inside the same PublishPlaceholder route that Session B rewrote PASS (holds) publishFooter.test.tsx 4/4 isolated
F046 TopBar composition Still in the shared AppShell layout surrounding the new Publish UI PASS (holds) topBar.test.tsx 7/7 isolated
F049 Footer git status chip Status log and status bar share the text-success/text-warning/text-destructive ladder PASS (holds) statusBar.test.tsx 3/3 isolated
F050 TopBar git indicator Same git plumbing consumed by F031’s CommitMessage useGitPublish PASS (holds) headerGitIndicatorModel.test.ts 9/9 + topBar.test.tsx 7/7 isolated
F068 Config service public snapshot PublishFooter uses configGetPublic → same service covered by the cycle-10 F053 smoke PASS (holds) configService.test.ts 3/3 in full-suite runs
F090 Designed empty states Shares the shadcn primitive layer Session B inherited from PASS (holds) emptyState.test.tsx 7/7 isolated
F022 PublishUnknownStateBanner Shares useGitPublish with the new CommitMessage surface PASS (holds) publishUnknownStateBanner.test.tsx in full-suite runs 1+3

All regression-adjacent features hold. No regressions detected on PASS features near modified code.

Preload API shape regression check

The load-bearing F033 fix modified src/preload/index.ts. Regression confirmation via tests/preload/apiShape.test.ts (17 tests, renderer run in full-suite runs 1 + 3 both PASS):

  • gitStreamSubscribe still exported as a function returning a function (unsubscribe).
  • firstRunStatusSubscribe still exported as a function returning a function.
  • All other API methods still return Promises.
  • The preload API shape contract held — no breaking IPC-shape drift introduced by Session B.

Step 6 — BLOCKED Feature Review

No BLOCKED features exist on the master list this cycle. Fix-10 did not newly block any feature. The previously-cleared live-git E2E (F029) remains covered by the mocked publishService + gitService.mocks suites — no new external dependency introduced by Session B.

Step 7 — MISSING Feature Spot Check (accidental ghost-implementation scan)

Per the prompt’s hardening-mode instructions, verified that the remaining 24 MISSING features have not been accidentally implemented under Session B’s churn:

F-entry Expected path(s) Present in tree?
F039 Document Creator renderer src/renderer/features/doc-creator/ ✗ (no subdirectory)
F045 Quick Browse renderer src/renderer/features/quick-browse/ ✗ (no subdirectory)
F087 Command palette src/renderer/features/command-palette/ or a cmdk-style component ✗ (not present)
F088 Keyboard shortcut wiring Global shortcut hook (e.g. useGlobalShortcuts) ✗ (not present)
F089 Context menus Right-click menu wiring ✗ (not present)
F093-F111 Phase 2 epic Various src/main/services/monitor/*, ai/*, email/*, etc. ✗ (none present)

Verified via Glob src/renderer/features/**/ and src/main/services/**/. No ghost implementations, no accidental promotions. MISSING count correctly decremented by exactly 4 (F030-F033).

Step 8 — Service-Layer Smoke Regression (cycle-10 baseline)

Cycle-10 landed a 5-consecutive-cycle streak of byte-stable direct service smokes (F008, F028+R2, F035, F036, F037, F038, F044) plus a new F053 smoke. Session B did not touch any service module the smokes target. Verified indirectly:

  • Full-suite runs 1 and 3 both show all service test files green (fileCopyService.test.ts 18/18, incomingFilesService.test.ts 7/7, configService.test.ts 3/3, determineFolderName.test.ts 16/16, stormFolderService.test.ts 20/20, quickBrowseService.test.ts 22/22, publishService.test.ts 12/12, publishHistoryService.test.ts 2/2, etc.).
  • Session B only added renderer-side modules. No changes under src/main/services/ or src/shared/.
  • Cycle-10’s direct-smoke fixture set (refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-10/) remains authoritative; no re-generation needed since the service layer did not change.

Service-layer stability: hold. No regression.

Detailed Findings

Fixes verified working

  1. F030 File Queue Rows, Parsed Metadata, And Row Actions — VERIFIED. 33/33 tests green across queueRowModel, usePublishQueueStore, fileList, and publishPlaceholder. All spec clauses (§6.6 row layout, §12 dedup by both basenames, §19 R2 per-row YouTube, Clear All, per-row Remove, legacy conversion with badge) exercised.
  2. F031 Commit Message + Upload State Machine — VERIFIED. 16/16 tests green across commitMessageModel and commitMessage. All spec clauses (§6.7 auto-populated commit msg, all four button label variants, all five disable gates, §8 publish entrypoint, touched flag logic) exercised. useGitPublish integration confirmed via the “clicking Upload invokes gitPublish with valid descriptors” test.
  3. F032 YouTube URL UI — VERIFIED. 4/4 direct tests green plus per-row coverage in F030’s fileList.test.tsx plus store-reapply coverage in usePublishQueueStore.test.ts. All spec clauses (§6.5 global input with live ✓/✗ + 11-char id preview, §11 same-batch semantics, §19 R2 per-row override) exercised.
  4. F033 Status Log UI + Live git:log Stream — VERIFIED. 11/11 tests green across statusLogModel and statusLog. Preload fix confirmed in source at src/preload/index.ts:153 (real ipcRenderer.on(GIT_LOG_EVENT_CHANNEL, listener) + unsubscribe). All spec clauses (§6.8 log surface, §7.4 git:log emission, §13 50-entry FIFO + • ✓ ⚠ ✗ icons + en-US 12h timestamp format) exercised. End-to-end path preload → store → DOM asserted by “installs the gitStreamSubscribe listener on mount and forwards events” test.

Fixes not resolved

None. All four fixes landed as claimed.

Regressions introduced

None. Zero PASS→anything demotions. Carryover sample (F009, F029, F034, F046, F049, F050, F068, F090, F022) all hold. Preload API shape contract intact (17/17 apiShape.test.ts). Service-layer contracts untouched by this pass. Full-suite runs 1 + 3 both green at 659/659.

One new test-side flake candidate surfaced in full-suite run-2: shadcn-smoke > opens the dialog and shows the titled input field (happy path) failed on synchronous text assertion after waitFor(dialog visible). Classified as MONITOR (test-side timing issue under parallel load; does not reproduce in 3 isolated runs; production code unaffected). Remediation is a one-line test-only fix in a future cycle.

Remaining work (24 MISSING features)

Unchanged from cycle-10 except Session B has closed:

  • Session B CLOSED: F030 → F031 → F032 → F033 (PASS).
  • Session C (next recommended): F087 → F088 → F089 (command palette + global shortcuts + context menus).
  • Session D: F039 (Document Creator renderer).
  • Session E: F045 (Quick Browse renderer).
  • Phase 2 epic (multi-session): F093-F111 (NHC monitor, AI, email, draft queue, rich dashboard, historical, notifications, QoL, audit compliance).

Master-List Update

No edits needed this verify pass. The fix-10 pass already updated F030-F033 to PASS with accurate Code path fields and evidence entries. This verification confirms:

  • F030: PASS held — queueRowModel.ts + usePublishQueueStore.ts + FileList.tsx all verified at the path cited in the master list.
  • F031: PASS held — commitMessageModel.ts + CommitMessage.tsx verified; touched flag behavior asserted in usePublishQueueStore.test.ts.
  • F032: PASS held — YouTubeSection.tsx verified; per-row override in FileList.tsx verified; reapply in queueRowModel.ts / usePublishQueueStore.ts verified.
  • F033: PASS held — preload fix verified in source; useGitLogStream.ts + statusLogModel.ts + StatusLog.tsx verified; main-side git:log emission unchanged.
  • F008, F009, F028+R2, F029, F034, F035, F036, F037, F038, F044, F046, F049, F050, F053, F068, F090 + all other 65 PASS features: no evidence drift; covered by full-suite runs 1 + 3 and/or isolated reruns this pass.

Totals (audited against the updated master list):

  • ^### F[0-9] → 111 ✓
  • ^- Status: PASS$ → 87 ✓
  • ^- Status: MISSING$ → 24 ✓
  • ^- Status: (FAIL|BLOCKED|PARTIAL|UNTESTED)$ → 0 ✓

Health Score: 87 / (87 + 0 + 0 + 0) = 100.0% ✓

Git Safety

  • No live git-publish E2E executed this verify pass. F029 derivative coverage held via mocked suites:
    • tests/main/publishService.test.ts — 12/12 PASS in runs 1 + 3.
    • tests/main/gitService.mocks.test.ts — 11/11 PASS in runs 1 + 3.
    • tests/main/publishHistoryService.test.ts — 2/2 PASS in runs 1 + 3.
    • tests/main/gitGetStatusHandlers.test.ts — 7/7 PASS in runs 1 + 3.
    • tests/renderer/useGitPublish.test.tsx — 2/2 PASS isolated + in full-suite runs.
  • The cycle-2 disposable-branch live E2E artifact (refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-2/publish-e2e-result.json) remains authoritative live evidence — no live git layer change landed in fix-10 (Session B touched only the renderer surface + preload event channel).
  • No disposable test branches created this pass. No remote refs touched. No main writes. No config.json mutations. No worktrees or stashes introduced. Git working tree unchanged.

Matches the cycle-6 through verify-9 guidance: use the live disposable-branch E2E only when a git-layer change lands; otherwise the static mocked-git suite is sufficient regression signal.

GUI / Screenshots

  • No live Electron launch attempted this pass. Session B adds new renderer surfaces (FileList, CommitMessage, YouTubeSection, StatusLog) which should eventually be visually verified, but DOM-level assertions via RTL (64 tests in the Session B isolated bundle) provide strong coverage for visual contract.
  • refinement-state/screenshots/cycle-10/ remains empty (cycle-10 created the directory; verify-10 does not repopulate). Recommend a next fix/verify cycle launch Electron to capture a refreshed Publish screen for the permanent artifact set.
  • All four new component surfaces have their DOM-level visual contract asserted in the Session B test bundle:
    • FileList: valid + invalid row chrome, converted badge, Clear All, per-row Remove, per-row YouTube input (aria-invalid).
    • CommitMessage: Input + Upload button, disable gates, button labels (“Upload 1 File” / “Upload N Files” / “Publishing…” / “Upload Files”).
    • YouTubeSection: success chip + extracted id, error chip + aria-invalid, role="status" polite live region.
    • StatusLog: ordered list with icons + timestamps + level-colored text, empty-state hint, Clear button.

Watch Flags Carried Forward To Cycle 11

  1. NEW: shadcn-smoke > opens the dialog and shows the titled input field (happy path) — MONITOR. Failed in test-run-2 under parallel load; did NOT reproduce in 3 isolated runs. Race condition between waitFor(dialog visible) and the following synchronous getByText('Publish label') assertion. Remediation recommendation: wrap the second assertion in its own waitFor in a future cycle. Test-only fix; production untouched. Upgrade trigger: ≥2 activations across cycle-11 or verify-11. Downgrade trigger: zero activations across cycle-11 + verify-11.
  2. Verify-8 watch flag: shadcn-smoke > keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open — RECOMMEND DOWNGRADE TO CLOSED. Held green for 4 consecutive cycles (cycle-9 + verify-9 + cycle-10 + verify-10, all 3/3 isolated + in-suite). The test-run-2 activation above was a DIFFERENT test within the same spec, not the watch-flagged one. Action at next cycle: mark CLOSED if cycle-11 continues the streak.
  3. 24 MISSING features remain uncovered — long-horizon debt. Recommended sequencing (revised after fix-10 closed Session B): Session C (F087-F089) → Session D (F039) → Session E (F045) → Phase 2 (F093-F111). Next fix cycle with non-empty scope should pick up Session C first (command palette + keyboard shortcuts + context menus — 3 features, user-facing affordance cluster).
  4. Service-layer byte-stability — FIFTH consecutive cycle holds. F008, F028+R2, F035, F036-F038, F044 direct smokes all byte-equal across 5+ cycles (cycle-7 through cycle-10). F053 direct-smoke added cycle-10 holds. Fix-10 added no service changes; the streak is intact.
  5. Build output stability after Session B landing. Renderer bundle hash moved from index-CZiEaSX0.js (988.72 kB) at cycle-10 to index-Dgd89L0d.js (1,030.80 kB) at fix-10 — an expected +42 kB growth in line with Session B’s scope. Future cycles should track this hash for drift detection; lint/typecheck/build all exit 0 on the new hash.
  6. Preload git:log channel is now LIVE. The cycle-10 fix-log claim that main emits webContents.send('git:log', …) since the beginning is still the source of truth; verify-10 confirms the preload listener is now installed. Unverified in this pass: live end-to-end stream from a real gitPublish → real log lines in the renderer. Recommend a next-cycle live publish test (disposable branch) with StatusLog visible, to confirm the main→preload→renderer pipe end-to-end under a real git operation.
  7. Full-suite flake margin is currently 1/3 (was 0/3 in cycle-10 and verify-9). One activation this pass on the new flake candidate. If cycle-11’s 3-pass full-suite trend remains 2-3 out of 3 green, the baseline is acceptable and the flake is purely test-side. If 2-3 out of 3 drops below, escalate.

Verification That State Is Accurately Recorded

Master-list totals audited directly via grep against refinement-state/refinement-functional-master-list.md:

  • ^### F[0-9] → 111 feature sections ✓
  • ^- Status: PASS$ → 87 ✓
  • ^- Status: MISSING$ → 24 ✓
  • ^- Status: (FAIL|BLOCKED|PARTIAL|UNTESTED)$ → 0 ✓

Totals sum: 87 + 24 + 0 + 0 + 0 + 0 = 111 ✓ Health Score: 87 / (87 + 0 + 0 + 0) = 100.0% ✓

Direct service smoke artifacts from cycle-10 remain authoritative (no service-layer change this pass). Session B isolated bundle 64/64 green confirms all four promoted features. Carryover isolated bundle 38/38 green confirms no regression on prior PASS features near modified code. Full-suite runs 2/3 fully green (659/659 each); run-2 single-test flake attributed to jsdom microtask timing under parallel load, does not reproduce in isolation. All three mechanical gates exit 0 on the post-fix source tree. Preload API shape contract held (17/17). Git working tree unchanged; no destructive ops.

Fix-10 verified in full. Four MISSING→PASS transitions confirmed. No regressions.

Evidence Index

  • Mechanical gates: refinement-state/functional-verify-10-artifacts/typecheck.log (exit 0), lint.log (exit 0), build.log (exit 0, 1,030.80 kB renderer bundle)
  • Full-suite runs: test-run-1.log (659/659, 71.35s), test-run-2.log (658/659, 61.71s — 1 shadcn-smoke flake), test-run-3.log (659/659, 45.02s)
  • Shadcn-smoke isolated: shadcn-smoke-isolated-1.log (16/16, 15.22s), shadcn-smoke-isolated-2.log (16/16, 8.12s), shadcn-smoke-isolated-3.log (16/16, 8.07s)
  • Session B fresh evidence (F030-F033): session-b-isolated.log (9 files / 64 tests, 13.07s)
  • Regression carryover (F009/F029/F034/F046/F049/F050/F090): carryover-isolated.log (7 files / 38 tests, 12.17s)
  • Master list: 87 PASS + 24 MISSING + 0 other = 111 (grep-audited)
  • Fix log: refinement-state/refinement-functional-fixes-10.md (Session B implementation record)

End of verify 10 report. Fix-10 verified: 4 MISSING→PASS transitions (F030, F031, F032, F033), 62 new tests added, 8 new test files, zero regressions, one new MONITOR watch flag (shadcn-smoke dialog title flake — test-only, non-regression), verify-8 watch flag recommended for CLOSE (4-consecutive-cycle green streak). Health score holds at 100.0%. 24 MISSING features remain as multi-session debt; recommended next sequence: Session C (F087-F089) → Session D (F039) → Session E (F045) → Phase 2 epic (F093-F111).

VERIFICATION_COMPLETE