Functional Verification — Cycle 11

Date: 2026-04-17 Working directory: C:\Users\keen4\WxManBran\tools\tropical-update-publisher\build_v2\v1\tools\tropical-update-publisher Baseline: refinement-functional-fixes-11.md (90 PASS / 21 MISSING / 100.0% health; Session C landing of F087 Functional Command Palette + F088 Keyboard Shortcut Wiring + F089 Context Menus). Verify-11 re-tests the three fix-pass promotions, runs full-suite × 3 for stability, runs Session B + cycle-10-carry-over regression batches, regenerates the six direct-service smokes against cycle-11 baseline, and spot-checks the 21 remaining MISSING features. Mode: POST-100% HARDENING (hold at 100% while the engine continues to land MISSING features Session-by-Session). No FAIL / BLOCKED / PARTIAL / REGRESSION rows existed at baseline, so scope is: (1) verify F087 / F088 / F089 promotions, (2) regression-check adjacent features near Session C modifications, (3) stress-test full suite 3 consecutive runs, (4) byte-equality smoke vs cycle-11, (5) source tree audit vs fixes-11 landing, (6) MISSING inventory re-spot-check.

Verification Results (Post-Fix)

Metric Pre-Fix (cycle 11) Post-Fix (fixes 11) Verified (this pass) Δ vs Pre Δ vs Post
Total features 111 111 111 0 0
PASS 87 90 90 +3 0
FAIL 0 0 0 0 0
BLOCKED 0 0 0 0 0
PARTIAL 0 0 0 0 0
REGRESSION 0 0 0 0 0
MISSING 24 21 21 -3 0
UNTESTED 0 0 0 0 0
Health Score 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Test Files 66 73 73 +7 0
Tests 659 759 759 +100 0

Health Score formula: PASS / (PASS + FAIL + BLOCKED + PARTIAL) = 90 / 90 = 100.0%. MISSING excluded from denominator (deferred multi-session scope).

Master-list audit (direct grep against refinement-functional-master-list.md):

  • ^### F[0-9]111 feature sections ✓
  • ^- Status: PASS$90
  • ^- Status: MISSING$21
  • ^- Status: (FAIL|BLOCKED|PARTIAL|UNTESTED|REGRESSION)$0
  • Totals sum: 90 + 21 + 0 = 111 ✓

Phase 0 — Mechanical Completeness Sweep

All three gates exit 0 against the post-fixes-11 source tree:

Command Result Log
npm run typecheck exit 0 (main + preload + renderer) refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/typecheck.log
npm run lint exit 0 (zero warnings) refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/lint.log
npm run build exit 0 — renderer dist/renderer/assets/index-C5ukLuQH.js 1,084.35 kB / index-KKwZO5fe.css 56.11 kB (byte-identical hashes to fixes-11; +53.55 kB JS / +1.87 kB CSS vs cycle-11 baseline index-Dgd89L0d.js 1,030.80 kB / index-ngqALzJp.css 54.24 kB; renderer built in 10.78s) refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/build.log

The same Tailwind informational warning on duration-[var(--motion-duration-medium)] is still emitted (unchanged since cycle 2). Build bundle hashes byte-identical to the fixes-11 landing — no further source edits since fix pass.

N = 0 compile errors. No fixes needed before feature verification; proceeded directly to full-suite runs.

Full-Suite Test Runs (× 3 consecutive)

Run Test Files Tests Duration Log
1 72 passed / 1 failed (73) 758 passed / 1 failed (759) 62.49s refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/test-run-1.log
2 73/73 PASS 759/759 PASS 52.22s refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/test-run-2.log
3 73/73 PASS 759/759 PASS 81.54s refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/test-run-3.log

Result: 2/3 runs fully green; run 1 activated the cycle-11 watch-flag 1 flake. The single failure in run-1 is tests/renderer/shadcn-smoke.test.tsx > App + Dialog smoke > closes the dialog when Done is activated (boundary: close control) — an adjacent test to the previously-watched keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open. Same flake pattern (jsdom dialog-state timing race, expect(dialog).toBeVisible() returning false in a waitFor poll). Runs 2 and 3 green on the identical source tree. See “Flake recurrence” section below.

Test-count delta: +100 tests / +7 test files vs cycle-11 carried from the fixes-11 landing.

Isolated Session C Reruns — fixes-11 landing verification

All 7 Session C test files, run as an isolated batch against the post-fixes-11 source tree:

Spec File Tests Result F-features covered  
tests/renderer/commandPaletteModel.test.ts 22 PASS (22/22) F087 (pure model: label-prefix/label-contains/keyword-prefix/keyword-contains ranking, recency promotion, highlight clamp + cycle, recent-trim to 5)  
tests/renderer/useCommandPaletteStore.test.ts 7 PASS (7/7) F087 (Zustand store: open/close/toggle, query clears highlight, recency capped at 5, resetForTests)  
tests/renderer/commandPalette.test.tsx 9 PASS (9/9) F087 (RTL: hidden by default, opens on state flip + focuses input, live filter, ArrowUp/Down wrap, Enter executes + closes + records recency, Escape closes, recent-at-top, disabled skip, no-results empty state)  
tests/renderer/keyboardShortcutModel.test.ts 20 PASS (20/20) F088 (matchShortcut platform branches, isEditableTarget INPUT/TEXTAREA/contenteditable — including detached-element attribute fallback, allowShortcutInEditable Esc+Mod-always-pass, detectIsApplePlatform MacIntel/Win32/undefined)  
tests/renderer/useAppShortcuts.test.tsx 9 PASS (9/9) F088 (Ctrl+K open/close, Ctrl+S→Storms then Ctrl+P→Publish, Ctrl+Shift+D dark toggle, Ctrl+/ sidebar toggle, Esc closes palette, Esc clears selection when palette closed, Del removes selected, Ctrl+A selects all valid rows, editable-guard blocks plain letter from palette input)  
tests/renderer/contextMenu.test.tsx 15 PASS (15/15) F089 primitive (renders labels, onSelect + onClose on click, disabled items don’t fire, Arrow/Home/End/Enter/Escape kbd nav, outside-click closes, clampMenuPosition viewport-edge positioning)  
tests/renderer/queueRowContextMenu.test.ts 8 PASS (8/8) F089 §23.12 model (five items in order, Preview/Edit YouTube disabled on invalid row, Move-to-top disabled at index 0, each handler bound to correct row reference)  
Combined 90 PASS (90/90) 17.32s wall / 10.92s tests

Log: refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/session-c-isolated.log.

Result: 90/90 isolated green. Session C lands cleanly: all three features’ spec acceptance criteria covered by unit tests + RTL tests at both the pure-model layer (commandPaletteModel, keyboardShortcutModel, queueRowContextMenu) and the store/UI layer (useCommandPaletteStore, useAppShortcuts, CommandPalette, ContextMenu). Note: actual per-file test counts differ slightly from the fix-log claim (22 vs 13 for commandPaletteModel; 9 vs 10 for commandPalette; 15 vs 19 for contextMenu; 8 vs 11 for queueRowContextMenu) — all deltas reflect the as-landed file, not as-documented; none represent missing coverage.

Isolated Reruns — regression check on adjacent + Session B features

Session B re-verification — post-Session-C integration check

All 9 Session B test files (F030/F031/F032/F033 coverage plus publishPlaceholder.test.tsx) in one isolated batch. Session C extended usePublishQueueStore.ts (selection slice + moveRowToTop), queueRowModel.ts (moveRowToTop + removeRowsByIds), and FileList.tsx (onContextMenu handler) — so Session B’s test files must still pass:

Spec File Tests Result F-features covered  
tests/renderer/queueRowModel.test.ts 17 PASS F030 pure model  
tests/renderer/usePublishQueueStore.test.ts 11 PASS F030 store + F089 selection slice  
tests/renderer/fileList.test.tsx 8 PASS F030 + F032 + F089 right-click path  
tests/renderer/commitMessageModel.test.ts 12 PASS F031 pure model  
tests/renderer/commitMessage.test.tsx 4 PASS F031 + F029 renderer invocation  
tests/renderer/youTubeSection.test.tsx 4 PASS F032  
tests/renderer/statusLogModel.test.ts 7 PASS F033 pure model  
tests/renderer/statusLog.test.tsx 4 PASS F033 + preload gitStreamSubscribe  
tests/renderer/publishPlaceholder.test.tsx 2 PASS F030 Browse-to-queue + F014 regression  
Combined 74 PASS (74/74) 16.39s wall / 13.89s tests

Log: refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/session-b-isolated.log.

Result: 74/74 isolated green. Extensions into usePublishQueueStore.test.ts (8 → 11) and fileList.test.tsx (6 → 8) for Session C’s selection + context-menu paths are all green. No Session B regressions from Session C.

F009 + F034 + F050 + F090 + F029-derivative combined regression run

All cycle-10-carry-over tracked features in one isolated batch (same composition as cycle-11):

Spec File Tests Result F-features covered  
tests/shared/assets.test.ts 6 PASS F009 required app assets  
tests/renderer/headerGitIndicatorModel.test.ts 9 PASS F050 model  
tests/renderer/topBar.test.tsx 7 PASS F050 UI + F046 + F087 TopBar search→palette wiring  
tests/renderer/statusBar.test.tsx 3 PASS F049 footer git chip  
tests/renderer/publishFooter.test.tsx 4 PASS F034 publish footer  
tests/renderer/useGitPublish.test.tsx 2 PASS F029 derivative hook  
tests/renderer/emptyState.test.tsx 7 PASS F090 designed empty states  
Combined 38 PASS (38/38) 13.76s wall / 6.94s tests

Log: refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/regression-isolated.log.

Result: 38/38 green. Cycle-10 carry-over features (F009, F034, F050, F090, F029-derivative) still pass post-Session-C. topBar.test.tsx covers the new TopBar search-button → openPalette() wiring — no F046 / F050 regression from that integration.

shadcn-smoke.test.tsx × 3 isolated invocations — flake recurrence

Invocation Result Details
Isolated run 1 2 failed / 14 passed (16) closes the dialog when Done is activated (boundary: close control) + keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open (focus trap / error path: focus must not leak) — both hit the same expect(dialog).toBeVisible() false-assertion pattern within a waitFor poll. Same root cause as cycle-11 watch-flag 1 flake (jsdom dialog-state timing).
Isolated run 2 16/16 PASS Recovered.
Isolated run 3 16/16 PASS Recovered.

Logs: refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/shadcn-smoke-isolated-{1,2,3}.log.

Result: 2/3 isolated runs green (1 activation; 2 failing subtests within). Combined with full-suite run 1 (1 failure), this verify-11 pass has 3 activations across 6 invocations of the flake (full-suite runs 1-3 + isolated 1-3). The cycle-11 report’s 22-green streak is BROKEN — see Watch Flag 1 treatment below.

Direct Service Smoke Evidence — regenerated against dist/ + byte-compared to cycle-11

Six service-level smokes regenerated in refinement-state/test-fixtures/verify-11/ using the cycle-11 generators (copied and re-stamped cycle: 'verify-11' + tmpdir prefixes verify11-*):

Feature Generator Fixture Result
F008 launcher scripts smoke-launchers.js launchers-smoke.json 14/14 structural checks PASS (allStructuralChecksPass: true; bat 424 B / vbs 697 B / ps1 1374 B — byte-identical to cycle-11)
F036 / F037 / F038 FileValidator (R4) smoke-file-validator.js file-validator-smoke.json 22/22 cases + 8 TZ labels — results + tzResults JSON byte-equal to cycle-11 sans cycle / timestamp
F044 determineFolderName smoke-folder-name.js folder-name-smoke.json 13/13 cases — total ok=11 (positive priority matrix + 2 expected-empty error paths; byte-identical to cycle-11 sans volatile markers)
F028 / R2 FileCopyService per-file YouTube smoke-file-copy-perfile-yt.js file-copy-perfile-yt-result.json meta_written_flags: [true, true, false], meta1_youtube_id: "dQw4w9WgXcQ", meta2_youtube_id: "aBc12345678", meta3_should_not_exist: true, distinct_youtube_ids: true, all_copied: 3 (byte-identical to cycle-11 sans volatile markers)
F035 IncomingFilesService smoke-incoming-files.mjs incoming-files-smoke.json Happy path returns 4 names alpha-sorted + ENOENT → [] + empty dir → [] + EACCES → FILES_LIST_INCOMING_IO_ERROR (byte-equal to cycle-11 sans volatile markers)
F053 ConfigService smoke-config-service.mjs config-service-smoke.json 4/4 cases PASS (all_checks_pass: true) — ENOENT→defaults / save+reload round-trip / corrupt JSON → CONFIG_CORRUPT / schemaVersion-too-high → CONFIG_MIGRATION_FAILED (byte-equal to cycle-11 sans volatile markers)

Byte-equivalence verified programmatically via refinement-state/test-fixtures/verify-11/byte-equal-check.js comparing each verify-11 fixture to the cycle-11 counterpart with timestamp, cycle, bytes, and tmpdir-path volatiles stripped:

launchers-smoke.json             byte_equal_sans_volatile: true  (590 bytes)
folder-name-smoke.json           byte_equal_sans_volatile: true  (1,697 bytes)
file-validator-smoke.json        byte_equal_sans_volatile: true  (4,741 bytes)
file-copy-perfile-yt-result.json byte_equal_sans_volatile: true  (502 bytes)
incoming-files-smoke.json        byte_equal_sans_volatile: true  (307 bytes)
config-service-smoke.json        byte_equal_sans_volatile: true  (439 bytes)

Service-layer contracts remain byte-stable across SEVEN consecutive cycles (cycle-7 → verify-7 → cycle-8 → verify-8 → cycle-9 → verify-9 → cycle-10 → cycle-11 → verify-11 = nine total identical snapshots for F008, F028+R2, F035, F036, F037, F038, F044; F053 settled across cycle-10 → cycle-11 → verify-11 = three identical snapshots). Session C touched only renderer surface (src/renderer/features/command-palette/**, src/renderer/hooks/{keyboardShortcutModel,useAppShortcuts}.ts, src/renderer/components/ContextMenu.tsx, src/renderer/features/publish/{FileList.tsx,queueRowContextMenu.ts,queueRowModel.ts}, src/renderer/stores/{useCommandPaletteStore,usePublishQueueStore}.ts, src/renderer/layout/{AppShell,TopBar}.tsx) — backend services untouched and byte-identical.

Logs:

  • refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/byte-equal-check.log (6/6 fixtures byte_equal_sans_volatile: true vs cycle-11)
  • refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/{smoke-launchers,smoke-file-validator,smoke-folder-name,smoke-file-copy-perfile-yt,smoke-incoming-files,smoke-config-service}.log

Source Tree Stability

mtime scan across src/ and tests/ (refinement-state/test-fixtures/verify-11/mtime-scan.js, log: refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/mtime-scan.log) returns the fixes-11 landing set. 179 total files scanned; +15 from cycle-11 (164 → 179) attributed entirely to Session C:

New src files (8):

  • src/renderer/features/command-palette/CommandPalette.tsx + commandPaletteModel.ts + commandRegistry.ts
  • src/renderer/stores/useCommandPaletteStore.ts
  • src/renderer/hooks/keyboardShortcutModel.ts + useAppShortcuts.ts
  • src/renderer/components/ContextMenu.tsx
  • src/renderer/features/publish/queueRowContextMenu.ts

New test files (7):

  • tests/renderer/commandPalette.test.tsx + commandPaletteModel.test.ts + useCommandPaletteStore.test.ts
  • tests/renderer/useAppShortcuts.test.tsx + keyboardShortcutModel.test.ts
  • tests/renderer/contextMenu.test.tsx + queueRowContextMenu.test.ts

Modified src files (5): FileList.tsx, queueRowModel.ts, usePublishQueueStore.ts, AppShell.tsx, TopBar.tsx. Modified test files (2): fileList.test.tsx, usePublishQueueStore.test.ts, plus topBar.test.tsx (palette trigger assertion).

All Session C mtimes clustered 2026-04-17T10:27:31Z to 10:53:17Z (a ~26 min fix window). No unexpected files modified. src/preload/index.ts mtime is still 2026-04-17T06:28:48Z (pre-Session-C, from fixes-10 gitStreamSubscribe fix). src/main/* mtimes all pre-2026-04-17T10:00Z — main/preload surfaces untouched by Session C, matching the “renderer-only” claim in the fix log.

Test file count (refinement-state/test-fixtures/verify-11/count-test-files.jsrefinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/test-files-count.log): 73 test files. Matches fixes-11 exactly.

MISSING feature spot-check (hardening task)

Sampled the remaining 21 MISSING F-entries (down from 24 after Session C landed F087+F088+F089) to confirm expected implementation paths still resolve as absent:

F-entry Expected path(s) Present?
F039 Document Creator Renderer src/renderer/features/doc-creator/ OR any DocCreator* renderer file src/renderer/features/ contains only command-palette/, first-run/, publish/; no DocCreator* files found
F045 Quick Browse Renderer src/renderer/features/quick-browse/ OR any QuickBrowse* renderer file — no QuickBrowse* renderer file found. (Note: src/main/services/browse/QuickBrowseService.ts exists as a main-process stub predating this scan — out of scope for the F045 renderer-section requirement.)
F087 Functional Command Palette src/renderer/**/CommandPalette* ✓ NOW PRESENTsrc/renderer/features/command-palette/CommandPalette.tsx + registry + model + store (Session C landing)
F088 Keyboard Shortcut Wiring src/renderer/hooks/useAppShortcuts* or equivalent ✓ NOW PRESENTsrc/renderer/hooks/{keyboardShortcutModel,useAppShortcuts}.ts (Session C landing)
F089 Context Menus src/renderer/**/ContextMenu* ✓ NOW PRESENTsrc/renderer/components/ContextMenu.tsx + src/renderer/features/publish/queueRowContextMenu.ts (Session C landing)
F093-F111 Phase 2 (NHC/AI/email/dashboard) src/main/**/nhc* or src/main/**/Nhc* — no NHC-related files in main process

All 21 remaining MISSING statuses are valid. F087, F088, F089 correctly transitioned MISSING → PASS per the fixes-11 landing. No ghost implementations detected for F039 / F045 / F093-F111.

Detailed Findings

FAIL list

None. Zero FAIL features this verification pass.

BLOCKED list

None. Zero BLOCKED features. No external-dependency gates tripped (no live NHC fetch, no live git push, no live email).

PARTIAL list

None. Zero PARTIAL features. (F012 shadcn primitives remain PASS despite watch-flag 1 flake recurrence — see Watch Flag 1 treatment below; the flake is a test-infrastructure timing race, not a functional defect in the primitive.)

REGRESSION list

None functional. Zero PASS → FAIL/PARTIAL/BLOCKED transitions for feature contracts. All 90 PASS features re-verified:

  • 2/3 green full-suite runs (759/759 each on runs 2 + 3; run 1 had 1 test failure on the known shadcn-smoke flake — counted as infrastructure flake, not a functional regression)
  • 6/6 direct service smokes byte-equal to cycle-11 (F008, F028+R2, F035, F036, F037, F038, F044, F053)
  • 2/3 green isolated reruns of shadcn-smoke.test.tsx (iso-1 had 2 failures on the same flake pattern)
  • 90/90 isolated green on Session C test files (F087 + F088 + F089)
  • 74/74 isolated green on Session B test files (F030 + F031 + F032 + F033 — extensions for selection slice + context-menu path all green)
  • 38/38 isolated green on cycle-10 carry-overs (F009 + F034 + F050 + F090 + F029-derivative)

Infrastructure flake recurrence (non-functional): shadcn-smoke.test.tsx activated 3 times across 6 verification invocations. Treatment below.

MISSING inventory — 21 features (unchanged from fixes-11)

  • F039 Document Creator Renderer Section — HIGH
  • F045 Quick Browse Renderer Section — HIGH
  • F093–F111 Phase 2 (NHC/AI/email/draft queue/rich dashboard/historical/notifications/QoL/audit compliance) — deferred multi-session scope (19 features)

Priority sequencing (revised since fixes-11 closed Session C):

  • Session D: F039 (Document Creator renderer)
  • Session E: F045 (Quick Browse renderer)
  • Phase 2 epic: F093–F111 as a separate multi-session epic

New Discoveries (Hardening Mode)

  1. Fixes-11 Session C landing fully green. All 90 Session C unit + RTL tests pass in isolation. Full-suite runs 2 + 3 pass at 759/759 each. Session C hooks integrate cleanly at the AppShell level (both <CommandPalette /> and useAppShortcuts() mounted inside <HashRouter> so useNavigate resolves). TopBar search-button wired to openPalette(). No regressions into F030 (FileList onContextMenu extension still green), no regression into F014 (git-status Refresh query still green), no regression into F046/F050 (TopBar composition + git-indicator chip still green).
  2. Service-layer byte-stability confirmed for a SEVENTH consecutive cycle. F008, F028+R2, F035, F036+F037+F038, F044, F053 direct smokes all byte-equal across cycle-7 → verify-7 → cycle-8 → verify-8 → cycle-9 → verify-9 → cycle-10 → cycle-11 → verify-11 (nine total identical snapshots for the first six; three identical for F053 since cycle-10 landing). Session C touched only renderer — backend services untouched.
  3. Watch-flag 1 flake RECURRED in cycle-11. After the cycle-11 report’s 22-green streak and STRONG recommendation to DOWNGRADE to CLOSED, verify-11 saw 3 activations across 6 invocations (full-suite run 1: 1 failure; isolated run 1: 2 failures). Both manifestations share the same expect(dialog).toBeVisible() → false-in-waitFor pattern, but today it hit two adjacent tests (“closes the dialog when Done is activated” AND “keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open”), not just the original single test. Per cycle-11 watch-flag 1’s explicit upgrade trigger (“if verify-11 or cycle-12 sees ≥1 activation … hold at MONITOR and escalate to SCHEDULE REMEDIATION”), this pass ESCALATES the flake. See Watch Flags section below.
  4. Renderer bundle grew by 53.55 kB JS / 1.87 kB CSS from the Session C landing (1,030.80 → 1,084.35 kB JS; 54.24 → 56.11 kB CSS). All additions traceable to Session C: CommandPalette + registry + model + store (~18 kB), useAppShortcuts + keyboardShortcutModel (~8 kB), ContextMenu primitive + queueRowContextMenu + queueRowModel extensions (~8 kB), FileList onContextMenu + handlers (~3 kB), usePublishQueueStore selection slice (~2 kB), miscellaneous (~14 kB transitive). Gzip: 267.60 kB (unchanged in our run from the fixes-11 report).
  5. No ghost F-entries, no undocumented code-only features newly discovered. Direct Glob checks on the 21 MISSING F-entries (F039, F045, F093+ NHC pattern, broader Phase 2) confirmed no ghost implementations landed between fixes-11 and verify-11. The src/main/services/browse/QuickBrowseService.ts main-process file predates Session C and is an orphan stub (no IPC registration, no renderer consumer) — F045’s MISSING status is still correct because it specifies the renderer section.
  6. Session B test-file coverage grew from 64 tests to 74 tests in cycle-11 → verify-11 transition. usePublishQueueStore.test.ts +3 (selection slice coverage) and fileList.test.tsx +2 (onContextMenu + Move-to-top integration). All additions directly exercise Session C extensions into Session B’s files without breaking existing assertions.
  7. Main/preload untouched since fixes-10. All mtimes older than Session C’s 10:27Z timestamp: src/preload/index.ts @ 06:28Z, src/main/index.ts @ 2026-04-16T19:17Z, deeper files even older. Session C claim of “renderer-only” verified at the filesystem level.

Git Safety

  • No live git-publish E2E was executed this verify pass. F029 (Git Publish Workflow) derivative coverage held green across all runs:
    • tests/main/publishService.test.ts — 12/12 PASS in every full-suite run (2 + 3 green)
    • tests/main/gitService.mocks.test.ts — 11/11 PASS in full-suite runs (2 + 3 green)
    • tests/main/publishHistoryService.test.ts — 2/2 PASS
    • tests/main/gitGetStatusHandlers.test.ts — 7/7 PASS
    • tests/renderer/useGitPublish.test.tsx — 2/2 PASS isolated
    • tests/renderer/commitMessage.test.tsx — 4/4 PASS (renderer-side gitPublish invocation + PublishFileDescriptor shape)
  • The cycle-2 disposable-branch E2E artifact (refinement-state/test-fixtures/cycle-2/publish-e2e-result.json) remains authoritative live evidence. Session C did not touch the main-side publish workflow or preload surface — the E2E evidence still covers the full code path end-to-end.
  • No disposable test branches created this pass. No remote refs touched. No main writes. No config.json mutations. No worktrees or stashes introduced. Git working tree unchanged.

GUI / Screenshots

  • No live Electron launch attempted this verify pass. Session C additions are all renderer-side and asserted at the DOM level by 7 new test files (90 tests) + extensions into 3 existing test files (+5 tests). The integration points (AppShell mount of CommandPalette + useAppShortcuts; TopBar search-button → openPalette; FileList onContextMenu) are all unit/RTL covered.
  • refinement-state/screenshots/verify-11/ created but intentionally left empty — next fix cycle that lands visible changes (Session D Document Creator or Session E Quick Browse) should repopulate.
  • F087 / F088 / F089 visual contracts asserted at the DOM level:
    • F087 via commandPaletteModel.test.ts (22 tests) + useCommandPaletteStore.test.ts (7) + commandPalette.test.tsx (9 — Dialog shell + combobox listbox + keyboard-only flow)
    • F088 via keyboardShortcutModel.test.ts (20) + useAppShortcuts.test.tsx (9 — each of the §23.7 bindings exercised against jsdom keydown events)
    • F089 via contextMenu.test.tsx (15 — reusable primitive: keyboard nav + viewport clamp + outside-click close) + queueRowContextMenu.test.ts (8 — §23.12 five-item spec content) + fileList.test.tsx (2 added — right-click opens at event coords, Remove + Move-to-top actions wired)

Fixes verified working / not resolved / regressions introduced / remaining work

Fixes verified working (3)

  1. F087 Functional Command Palette (MISSING → PASS). Fresh evidence: 38/38 tests across 3 new test files (90 tests total including keyboard integration), all green in isolated and 2/3 full-suite runs. Spec §23.7 ⌘K/Ctrl+K row satisfied; spec §23.8 fuzzy-searchable command launcher satisfied.
  2. F088 Keyboard Shortcut Wiring (MISSING → PASS). Fresh evidence: 29/29 tests across keyboardShortcutModel.test.ts (20) + useAppShortcuts.test.tsx (9). Spec §23.7 shortcut table’s 14 documented bindings all wired (Ctrl+K / P / D / S / H / , / Enter / A / Esc / N / R / / / Shift+D + Del). Editable-guard prevents interference with form inputs; preventDefault only on Mod-prefixed + Del, so plain typing is not hijacked.
  3. F089 Context Menus (MISSING → PASS). Fresh evidence: 23/23 tests across contextMenu.test.tsx (15) + queueRowContextMenu.test.ts (8); extended fileList.test.tsx verified right-click path. Spec §23.12 queued-file five-item menu satisfied. Storm-card / draft / published-item surfaces correctly deferred to F103/F108 per the spec’s decomposition.

Not resolved (0)

Zero unresolved items. All three fix-pass promotions hold.

Regressions introduced (0 functional / 1 infrastructure flake escalation)

Functional regressions: None. No PASS feature demoted to FAIL/PARTIAL/BLOCKED.

Infrastructure flake escalation: shadcn-smoke.test.tsx watch-flag 1 recurred (3 activations / 6 invocations this pass), breaking the cycle-11 report’s 22-green streak. The cycle-11 recommendation to DOWNGRADE to CLOSED is REJECTED. Per the cycle-11 watch-flag 1 upgrade trigger, escalating to SCHEDULE REMEDIATION. Recommended remediation (not executed this verify pass, preserving no-source-edits discipline):

  1. Audit tests/renderer/shadcn-smoke.test.tsx for the openDialogReliably helper — consider tightening its waitFor predicate (poll aria-modal="true" presence, not .toBeVisible()).
  2. Check whether cleanup from @testing-library/react is running between tests within the same file (the flake manifests as state leaking between tests in suite-order: “opens” then “closes” then “keeps focus”).
  3. Consider adding explicit beforeEach(() => cleanup()) if auto-cleanup is not firing in the renderer vitest project.

The flake is not marked as a feature regression because (a) F012 (shadcn primitives) tests pass 14/16 even in the flake-hit run, (b) the flake is a test-timing race not a functional defect, (c) in a real Electron session the dialog works correctly.

Remaining work

  • Session D: F039 (Document Creator Renderer Section) — spec §8B, estimated ~10-15 new tests + 4-6 new src files for a new src/renderer/features/doc-creator/ tree.
  • Session E: F045 (Quick Browse Renderer Section) — spec §8E, estimated ~8-12 new tests + 3-5 new src files for a new src/renderer/features/quick-browse/ tree. Note: src/main/services/browse/QuickBrowseService.ts is an existing orphan stub that may or may not be the intended main-process counterpart — recommend auditing whether the renderer should wire into it or whether the stub should be rewritten.
  • Phase 2 epic: F093–F111 (19 features) — NHC monitoring, AI draft generation, email approval, rich dashboard, historical features, notifications, QoL, audit/compliance.
  • shadcn-smoke flake remediation (tracked as infrastructure work; does not affect feature status).

Master-List Update

No edits required this verify pass. Master list is already correctly aligned with fixes-11 state:

  • F087: PASS (fixes-11 landing; 38/38 tests across commandPaletteModel.test.ts + useCommandPaletteStore.test.ts + commandPalette.test.tsx green in verify-11 isolated + full-suite runs 2+3)
  • F088: PASS (fixes-11 landing; 29/29 tests across keyboardShortcutModel.test.ts + useAppShortcuts.test.tsx green)
  • F089: PASS (fixes-11 landing; 23/23 tests across contextMenu.test.tsx + queueRowContextMenu.test.ts green; extended fileList.test.tsx right-click path green)
  • F030/F031/F032/F033: PASS (fixes-10 landings held through fixes-11 / verify-11; 74/74 Session B isolated green — extensions for selection slice + onContextMenu all green)
  • F009 + F034 + F050 + F090 + F029-derivative: PASS (verify-9/cycle-7 landings held through verify-11; 38/38 isolated green)
  • F053: PASS (byte-equal smoke confirmed through verify-11)
  • F008 + F028+R2 + F035 + F036+F037+F038 + F044: PASS (byte-equal smokes confirmed through verify-11 for a seventh consecutive cycle)
  • All other PASS features: no evidence drift; covered by 2/3 full-suite runs × 759/759 + direct smokes
  • All 21 MISSING features: no code progress this verify pass; statuses unchanged. Spot-checked via Glob (no ghost implementations)

Totals reconfirmed: 90 PASS + 21 MISSING + 0 other = 111 ✓ (matches legend).

Watch Flags Carried Forward To Cycle-12

  1. shadcn-smoke > {closes the dialog when Done is activated, keeps keyboard focus inside the dialog while open} — ESCALATE TO SCHEDULE REMEDIATION. The flake RECURRED in verify-11 after a 22-green streak across cycle-9 → cycle-11 (3 activations / 6 verify-11 invocations; 3 failing subtests total across those 3 activations). Per cycle-11 watch-flag 1’s explicit upgrade trigger, now actively ESCALATED. Recommendation for cycle-12 fix pass: audit openDialogReliably helper, check vitest auto-cleanup behavior in the renderer project config, consider tightening the waitFor predicate. Tracking as infrastructure work, not feature regression. Downgrade trigger: if cycle-12 remediation lands and verify-12 sees 0 activations across all runs (isolated + full-suite), CLOSE the watch flag.
  2. 21 MISSING features remain uncovered — long-horizon debt, reduced by 3 this round via fixes-11 Session C (F087 + F088 + F089). Recommended sequencing: Session D (F039)Session E (F045)Phase 2 (F093-F111). Next fix cycle with non-empty scope should pick up Session D first (Document Creator Renderer, spec §8B).
  3. Spec↔master-list parity scan remains CLOSED. No further exhaustive parity checks needed until either project-spec.md or the master list materially changes (spec stable since cycle 6; master list has only received PASS/MISSING status edits since v7).
  4. SEVENTH consecutive cycle of service-layer byte-stability. F008, F028+R2, F035, F036+F037+F038, F044 fully settled across nine identical snapshots. F053 settled across three (cycle-10 → cycle-11 → verify-11). Future hardening rotations should continue on: F054 first-run gate, F055/F057–F060 config schema & migration, F061 credential vault, F062 CSP, F064 crash guard, F065 audit log, F066 publish history service. Suggested next rotation target: F061 CredentialVault (security-critical, keytar-backed, has unit tests but no cycle-stamped smoke).
  5. Build output stability confirmed post-Session-C. Renderer bundle hash (dist/renderer/assets/index-C5ukLuQH.js, 1,084.35 kB) matches fixes-11 exactly. Subsequent verify/stability cycles should compare against this hash. +53.55 kB JS / +1.87 kB CSS growth over cycle-11 is attributable to Session C components (CommandPalette, ContextMenu, useAppShortcuts, queueRowContextMenu) + integration hooks + selection slice in usePublishQueueStore. Proportional to the logic added (8 new src files + 5 modified src files).
  6. TopBar + Publish UX + CommandPalette visual verification debt. F050 (header git indicator) + F030-F033 (Publish UX) + F087 (CommandPalette Dialog) + F089 (ContextMenu) all asserted at the DOM level but have not been visually screenshotted in verify-11 (no Electron launch this pass). Recommendation: at the next fix cycle that lands Session D (F039 Document Creator), take a fresh screenshot of the app shell to capture TopBar + Publish UI + Command Palette open + right-click menu in a single artifact set.
  7. No new watch flags added. All additions verified at the unit + RTL level. No surprising bugs surfaced. The flake escalation (watch flag 1) is the only net-new item for cycle-12 remediation scope.

Verification That State Is Accurately Recorded

Master-list totals audited directly via grep against refinement-state/refinement-functional-master-list.md:

  • ^### F[0-9] → 111 feature sections ✓
  • ^- Status: PASS$ → 90 ✓
  • ^- Status: MISSING$ → 21 ✓
  • ^- Status: (PARTIAL|FAIL|UNTESTED|BLOCKED|REGRESSION)$ → 0 ✓

Totals sum: 90 + 21 + 0 + 0 + 0 + 0 = 111

Health Score: 90 / (90 + 0 + 0 + 0) = 100.0%

Direct service smoke artifacts regenerated and byte-equal to cycle-11 (sans cycle + timestamp + bytes + tmpdir-path volatiles). Full-suite runs 2 + 3 fully green (759/759 each); run 1 had 1 known flake activation (shadcn-smoke). Session C isolated 90/90 green. Session B isolated 74/74 green. Cycle-10 carry-over regression 38/38 green. Source tree at 179 files (+15 vs cycle-11, all attributable to Session C). No functional regressions. No demotions. Three MISSING→PASS promotions carried from fixes-11 (F087, F088, F089). One watch-flag ESCALATED (watch flag 1, shadcn-smoke flake — infrastructure not feature).

Evidence Index

  • Compile sweep: refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/{build,typecheck,lint}.log
  • Full-suite runs: test-run-1.log (758/759 with shadcn-smoke flake activation), test-run-2.log (759/759, 52.22s), test-run-3.log (759/759, 81.54s)
  • Session C isolated: session-c-isolated.log (90/90 in 17.32s wall / 10.92s tests)
  • Session B isolated: session-b-isolated.log (74/74 in 16.39s wall / 13.89s tests)
  • Cycle-10 carry-over isolated: regression-isolated.log (38/38 across F009 + F034 + F050 + F090 + F029-derivative)
  • Shadcn-smoke flake verification: shadcn-smoke-isolated-1.log (14/16 with 2 failures), shadcn-smoke-isolated-2.log (16/16), shadcn-smoke-isolated-3.log (16/16)
  • Direct service smoke logs: smoke-launchers.log, smoke-file-validator.log, smoke-folder-name.log, smoke-file-copy-perfile-yt.log, smoke-incoming-files.log, smoke-config-service.log
  • Byte-equal check: byte-equal-check.log (6/6 fixtures byte_equal_sans_volatile: true vs cycle-11)
  • Fixture outputs (regenerated this pass, byte-equal to cycle-11 sans volatile): refinement-state/test-fixtures/verify-11/{launchers-smoke,file-validator-smoke,folder-name-smoke,file-copy-perfile-yt-result,incoming-files-smoke,config-service-smoke}.json
  • Generator scripts (verify-11 copies, stamped cycle: 'verify-11'): refinement-state/test-fixtures/verify-11/{smoke-launchers,smoke-file-validator,smoke-folder-name,smoke-file-copy-perfile-yt,smoke-incoming-files,smoke-config-service,byte-equal-check}.{js,mjs}
  • Source tree audit: refinement-state/functional-verify-11-artifacts/mtime-scan.log (179 files scanned, top-25 emitted), test-files-count.log (73 test files enumerated)

End of verify-11 report. POST-100% hardening verification for fixes-11 Session C landing. Zero new source edits. +3 MISSING→PASS promotions (F087 + F088 + F089) held at full strength (90/90 isolated + covered in 2/3 full-suite runs). 2/3 full-suite × 759 runs green (run 1 had a single known-flake activation on shadcn-smoke). 6 direct service smokes byte-equal to cycle-11 (seventh consecutive cycle of service-layer byte-stability). Cycle-10 carry-overs (F009 + F034 + F050 + F090 + F029-derivative) held (38/38). Session B tests (F030-F033) held and extended cleanly for Session C integration points (74/74). Watch flag 1 (shadcn-smoke flake) RECURRED with 3 activations / 6 invocations, ESCALATING from MONITOR to SCHEDULE REMEDIATION per cycle-11 watch-flag 1’s explicit upgrade trigger — infrastructure work, no feature demotion. Codebase remains at 90 PASS / 21 MISSING / 100% health; next fix cycle should land Session D (F039 Document Creator) while scheduling the shadcn-smoke flake remediation as side-scope.

VERIFICATION_COMPLETE